Menu Close

Reply To: O God, Our Help in Ages Past

Home Workshop Forums Music Critiques, Please O God, Our Help in Ages Past Reply To: O God, Our Help in Ages Past

#2521

Lynn Martin
Administrator

Again, a very nice melody. This would work great in many contexts. It has considerable beauty and movement. For the harmony, I think it’s overly sophisticated for the simply elegant melody. A traditional harmonization without most of the pedal tones and chromatics, and with more selective use of counterpoint, would in my view work better.